Talk:Carmageddon!/@comment-32942753-20170926220650/@comment-33165688-20170927062701

Being "born outside of time" or not from Earth doesn't mean you had no ancestors, and the point people are making is not that Renet stopped existing, but that she COULDN'T exist in the first place if humans are all dead and cannot have future generations that produced her. She could never have been there in the first place if the Mutant Apocalypse Timeline was the main timeline. Being "outside of time" doesn't mean you are totally unconnected and unaffected by events.

And regardless of when she was born, she was arriving from the future and she was also aware of information FROM the future. Statements were made about what was going to happen, and those are contradicted by the Mutant Apocalypse arc.

And no, I do not buy for a second that septuagenarian turtles with no resources are suddenly going to "many times" save the world, or that she was just confused (she wasn't the only one who reacted to them), nor do I think that history would regard them as superheroes for the events of the series when most of their world-saving was effectively secret.

It IS quite straightforward: the Mutant Apocalypse Arc does not make any logical sense with previously established canon, no matter how many continuity pretzels are made. No respect for continuity and canon was shown.