Alfred Pennyworth (Crisis in a Half Shell)

In the New Earth Prime reality, Alfred Pennyworth is the former butler of the Wayne family. When his employers were killed and their son was adopted by, Alfred remained in Wayne Manor, defending it from anyone who might try to break in. Despite his efforts, the mansion fell into ruin.

Many years later, Bruce returned to the mansion, and an overjoyed Alfred recognized and embraced him. The butler's memories of another reality began to return, and he opened the doorway into the Bat-Cave.