User blog comment:The S/Fan Stuff - Stay or Go?/@comment-93957-20160724222719/@comment-995426-20160725060636

Well, the issue does seem murky. Some (technically) fan content enjoys great respect and prominence. Not just MNT Gaiden as I've mentioned before, but also unlicensed works that have involved big names in their production, like the Casey Jones fan film (with reprising voice actors) and the unofficial Image TMNT resolution comics (which involved Arseniy Dubakov, Kevin Eastman, Jim Lawson...) and Secrets of the Ooze webcomic (which official artist Sophie Campbell does as an unofficial side project). I can see that there's clearly a gulf between these works and, say...the relatively more personal and obscure fanfiction of User:Nikki Kiki zelonskie113.

Maybe there should be a distinction between licensed vs. prominent unlicensed vs. small-scale fan work, but the problem is that even the distinction between the latter two that I described will often be a matter of subjective opinion. Basically, the question of "notability," similar to the debate that constantly goes on at Wikipedia. If only we could settle on a set of criteria...

And as for Nikki Kiki zelonskie113, if we decide her work is of the less notable, I would still not be in favor of deleting it from the wiki (since she appears to edit them in good faith and I have no reason to believe otherwise), but instead moving its articles to subpages of her personal user space.