User blog comment:The S/Fan Stuff - Stay or Go?/@comment-93957-20160724222719/@comment-93957-20160725160811

I guess it boils down to this: Why does the content need to be here. Emphasis on both parts equally.

It isn't about


 * Why you want it to be here (or not)


 * Why it needs to be catalogued at all

But asking why it needs to be here. Does the Wiki benefit more by having it? Does the Wiki benefit less for not having it?

Again, remember that no other Wikis based on a series' canon tracks stuff like this. There's no Batman fan characters at the DC Wiki. No Spider-Man fangames on Marvel Wiki. No random made-up survivors on the Walking Dead Wiki. No fan comics on the Savage Dragon Wiki. Why would we, if not them?

All fan works are equal though if we do something new or different with the stuff, whether recategorizing or moving it. The only thing that would be iffy on moving it to another Wiki would be the quasi-official stuff like the Image conclusions. You can't play favorites with things like this.

I'm not sure what the relevance to who's complaining is, though... I received a few messages via the Facebook account over about a month and a half and the most recent ones came from a message board.